TEDxChange: Melinda French Gates
Progress on the MDGs, lessons learned from soda pop, and her definition of happiness.
September 20, 2010
Remarks by Melinda French Gates, co-chair and trustee
Well, I want to help dispel the myth, that investments in health and development have not made any progress or big impact. In fact, if you look the last 10 years, it’s amazing what’s happened with the Millennium Development goals. We’ve made more progress in the last 10 years, than in any period in history combined. In fact, the first of the eight Millennium Development goals is around poverty. It’s to reduce poverty by half. And what I’m here to tell you is that we’re on track with this Millennium Development goal. In fact, 1.3 billion people have lifted themselves out of poverty in the last 23 years. That’s 1.3 billion people, like this beautiful little girl. Now for me, I can’t imagine bigger impact.
One of my favorite parts about my job at the Gates Foundation is that I get to travel to the developing world, and I do that quite regularly. And, when I meet the mothers in so many of these remote places, I’m really struck by the things we have in common. They want what we want for our children, and that is for their children to grow up successful, to be healthy, and have a successful life. But I also see lots of poverty. And it’s quite jarring. Both in the scale and the scope of it. My first trip in India I was in a person’s home where they had dirt floors, no running water, no electricity, and that’s really what I see all over the world.
So in short, I’m startled by all the things that they don’t have. But I am surprised by one thing that they do have. Coca-Cola. Coke is everywhere. In fact, when I travel in the developing world, Coke feels ubiquitous. And so when I come back from these trips and I’m thinking about development and I’m flying home and I’m thinking, well, we’re trying to deliver condoms to people, or vaccinations, you know, Coke’s success kinda stops and makes you wonder. How is it that they can get Coke to these far-flung places. And if they can do that, why can’t governments and NGOs do the same thing. And I’m not the first person to ask this question. But I think as a community we still have a lot to learn.
You know, it’s staggering if you think about Coca-Cola. They sell 1.5 billion servings every single day. That’s like every man, woman and child on the planet having a serving of Coke every week. So why does this matter. Well, if we’re gonna speed up the progress and go even faster on the set of Millennium Development goals that we’ve set as a world, we need to learn from the innovators. And those innovators come from every single sector. I feel that if we can understand what makes something like Coca-Cola ubiquitous, we can apply those lessons then, for the public good.
Coke’s success is relevant because if we can analyze it, learn from it, then we can save lives. So that’s why I took a bit of time to study Coke. And I think there are really three things we can take away from Coca-Cola. They take real-time data, and immediately feed it back into the product. They tap into local entrepreneurial talent, and they do incredible marketing. So let’s start with the data. Now Coke has a very clear bottom line, they report to a set of shareholders—holders, they have to turn a profit. So they take the data, and they use it to measure progress. They have this very continuous feedback loop, they learn something, they put it back into the product, they put it back into the market. They have a whole team called Knowledge and Insight, it’s a lot like other consumer companies.
So if you’re running Namibia for Coca-Cola and you have 107 constituencies, you know where every can versus bottle of Sprite, Fanta or Coke was sold, whether it was a corner store, a supermarket or a pushcart. So if sales start to drop, then a person can identify the problem, and address the issue. Well let’s contrast that for a minute to development. In development the evaluation comes at the very end of the project. I’ve sat in a lot of those meetings. And by then, it is way too late to use the data. I had somebody from an NGO once describe it to me as bowling in the dark. They said, you know, you roll the ball, you hear some pins go down, it’s dark, you can’t see which ones go down until the lights come on, and then you can see your impact. Real-time data turns on the lights.
So what’s the second thing that Coke’s good at? Well, they’re good at tapping into that local entrepreneurial talent. Coke’s been in Africa since 1928, but most of the time, they couldn’t reach the distant markets because they had a system that was a lot like in the developing—developed world, which was, a large truck rolling down a street, and in Africa, the remote places it’s hard to find a good road. But Coke noticed something, they noticed that local people were taking the product, buying it in bulk, and then reselling it in these hard-to-reach places.
And so they took a bit of time to learn about that. And they decided in 1990 that they wanted to start training these local entrepreneurs, giving them small loans, they set them up as what they called micro-distribution centers. And those local entrepreneurs then, hire salespeople who go out with bicycles and pushcarts and wheelbarrows to sell the product. So there are now some 3,000 of these centers employing about 15,000 people in Africa. In Tanzania and Uganda, they represent 90 percent of Coke sales.
So let’s look at the development side. What is it that governments and NGOs can learn from Coke. Well, the governments and NGOs need to tap into that local entrepreneurial talent as well because, the locals know how to reach the very hard-to-serve places, and they also know they’re ma—neighbors and they know what motivates them to make change. I think a great example of this is Ethiopia’s new ex— health extension program. The government noticed in Ethiopia that many of the people were so far away from a health clinic, they were over a day’s travel away to [sic] a health clinic, so if you’re in an emergency situation or you’re a mom about to deliver a baby, forget it, to get to the health care center.
They decided that wasn’t good enough, so they went to India and studied the Indian state of Kara that also had a system like this, and they adapted it for Ethiopia. And in 2003 the government of Ethiopia entered—started this new system in their own country, they trained 35,000 health extension works to deliver care directly to the people. So in just five years, their ratio went from one worker for every 30,000 people, to one worker for every 2,500 people.
Now think about how this can change people’s lives. Health extension workers can help with so many things, whether it’s family planning, prenatal care, immunizations for the children, or advising a woman to get to the facility on time for an on-time delivery. That is having real impact in a country like Ethiopia, and it’s why you see their child mortality numbers coming down 25 percent from 2000 to 2008. In Ethiopia there are hundreds of thousands of children living, because of this health extension worker program.
So what’s the next step for Ethiopia, well they’re already starting to talk about this. They’re starting to talk about how do you have the health community workers generate their own ideas. How do you incent them based on the impact that they’re getting out in those remote villages. That’s how you tap into local entrepreneurial talent and you unlock people’s potential.
Now the third component of Coke’s success is marketing. Ultimately, Coke’s success depends on one crucial fact. And that is, that people want a Coca-Cola. Now the reason these micro-entrepreneurs can sell all—sell or make a profit, is they have to sell every single bottle in their pushcart or their wheel barrel. So they, they rely on Coca-Cola…in terms of its marketing, and what’s the secret to their marketing. Well, it’s aspirational. It associates that product with the kind of life that people wanna live. So even though it’s a global company, they take a very local approach.
Coke’s global campaign slogan is “Open happiness.” But they localize it. And they don’t just guess what people makes them happy [sic], they go to places like Latin America and they realize that happiness there is associated with family life. And in South Africa, they associate happiness with seriti, or community respect. Now that played itself out in the World Cup campaign. Let’s listen to this song that Coke created for it, “Waving Flag” by a Somali hip-hop artist.
It feels pretty good, right? Well they didn’t stop there, they localized it into 18 different languages, and it went number one on the pop chart in 17 countries. It reminds me of a song that I remember from my childhood—“I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing,” that also went to number one on the pop charts. Both songs have something in common—that same appeal of celebration and unity.
So how does health and development market? Well, it’s based on avoidance, not aspirations. Sure you’ve heard some of these messages. Use a condom, don’t get AIDS. Wash your hands, you might not get diarrhea. It doesn’t sound like anything like “Waving Flag” to me. And I think we make a fundamental mistake, we make an assumption, we think that if people need something, we don’t have to make them want that. And I think that’s a mistake.
And there’s some indications around the world that this is starting to take—to change. One example is sanitation. We know, that a million and a half children die a year from diarrhea, and a lot of it is because of open defecation. But there’s a solution. You build a toilet. But what we’re finding around the world over and over again is if you build a toilet, and you leave it there, it doesn’t get used. People use it—reuse it for a slab for their home, they sometimes store grain in it, I’ve even seen it used for a chicken coop.
But what does marketing really entail that would make a sanitation solution get a result in diarrhea. Well, you work with the community, you start to talk to them about why open defecation is something that shouldn’t be done in the village, and they agree to that. But then you take the toilet, and you position it as a modern, trendy convenience. One state in northern India has gone so far as to link toilets to courtship. And it works. Look at these headlines. I’m not kidding. Women are refusing to marry men without toilets, no look, no “I do.” Now—It’s not just a funny headline. It’s innovative. It’s an innovative marketing campaign. But more importantly, it saves lives.
Take a look at this. This is a room full of young men and my husband Bill, and can you guess what the young men are waiting for? They’re waiting to be circumcised. Can you believe that? We know that circumcision reduces HIV infection by 60 percent in men. And when we first heard this result inside the Foundation, I have to admit, Bill and I were scratching our heads a little bit and we’re saying, but who’s gonna volunteer for this procedure. But it turns out, the men do. Because they’re hearing from their girlfriends that they prefer it, and the men also believe it improves their sex life. So if we can start to understand, what people really want in health and development, we can change communities, and we can change whole nations.
So why is this so important. Well let’s talk about what happens when this all comes together, when you tie the three things together. And polio I think is one of the most powerful examples. We’ve seen a 99 percent reduction in polio in 20 years. So if you look back to 1988 there are about 350,000 cases of polio on the planet that year. In 2009 we’re down to 1,600 cases. Well how did that happen. Let’s look at a country like India. They have over a billion people in this country. But they have 35,000 local doctors who report paralysis and clinicians, a huge reporting system in chemists. They have 2.5 million vaccinators.
But let me make the story a little bit more concrete for you. Let me tell you the story of Sriram, an 18-month old boy, in Bihar, a northern state in India. This year, on August 8th, he felt paralysis. And on the 13th, his parents took him to the doctor. On August 14th and 15th they took a stool sample, and by the 25th of August, it was confirmed he had Type I polio. By August 30th, a genetic test was done, and we knew what strain of polio Sriram had. Now it could’ve come from one of two places. It could’ve come from Nepal, just to the north across the border, or from Jharkhand, the state just to the south. Luckily the genetic testing proved that in fact this strain came north because had it come from the south it would’ve had a much wider impact in terms of transmission, so many more people would’ve been affected.
So what’s the end game? Well, on September 4th there was a huge mop-up campaign, which is what you do in polio. They went out and where Sriram lives, they vaccinated 2 million people. So, in less than a month, we went from one case of paralysis to a targeted vaccination program. And I’m happy to say only one other person in that area got polio. That’s how you keep a huge outbreak from spreading. And it shows what can happen, when local people have the data in their hands, they can save lives.
Now one of the challenges in polio still is marketing, but it might not be what you think. It’s not the marketing on the ground, it’s not telling the parents, if you see paralysis take your child to the doctor or get your child vaccinated. We have a problem with marketing in the donor community. The G8 nations have been incredibly generous on polio over the last 20 years. But we’re starting to have something called polio fatigue, and that is that the donor nations aren’t wanting to fund polio any longer. So by next summer, we’re slated to run out of money on polio.
So we are 99 percent of the way there, on this goal, and we’re about to run short of money. And I think that if the marketing were more aspirational, if we could focus as a community on how far we’ve come, and how amazing it would be to eradicate this disease, we could put polio fatigue and polio behind us. And if we could do that, we could stop vaccinating everybody worldwide in all of our countries for polio. And it would only be the second disease ever wiped off the face of the planet. And we are so close, and this victory is so possible.
So if Coke’s marketers came to me, and asked me, to define happiness…I’d say my vision of happiness is a mother holding a healthy baby in her arms. To me, that is deep happiness. And so if we can learn lessons from the innovators in every sector, then the future we make together, that happiness can be just as ubiquitous as Coca-Cola.
Thank you.September 20, 2010
Melinda French Gates talks about global progress toward the Millennium Development Goals, lessons learned from the field, and her definition of happiness.